Why would anyone bother with concealed carry revolvers, some people ask, since there are so many more advantages with modern guns? So many striker-fired compact pistols out there with greater capacity, lighter triggers and easier responses, it would seem like there just isn't as much point anymore.
They have endured the advance of time and firearm design. But what's the obsession? Shouldn't revolvers go the way of the dodo now that there are bigger, better, more technologically advanced handguns out there?
Actually, no. Despite whatever their perceived shortcomings might be, a CCW revolver is every bit the solid choice of concealed carry gun today as they ever were. Let's go over a few reasons why.
Revolvers Are Reliable
While many semi-autos are reliable, revolvers have a reputation for rugged dependability. They aren’t flawless—Colt Pythons, for example, can shoot out of time with too much .357 Magnum—but few issues will stop a revolver from going “bang” when you pull the trigger.
There are fewer working parts and fewer things that can go wrong. Fewer shots on hand, to be sure...but you can count on every one of them to go out the barrel.
Shooting A Revolver Couldn't Be Simpler
Every single thing ever said lauding of striker guns over their operational simplicity applies equally to a concealed carry revolver. There are pretty much two steps: point, then shoot. Reload as needed.
The days of single-action revolvers being the dominant form of the gun have been over since the early 20th century; double-actions are the dominant designs of revolvers - be they compact for concealed carry or full-size for handgun hunting.
However, the drawback is that the trigger pull is a bit hard, as the typical double-action trigger pull on a wheel gun is between 10 and 14 pounds, depending on the model...but with practice, incredible speed and accuracy are definitely possible.
Revolvers Last
One of the real advantages of revolvers is their longevity. Working pistols from the 1800s turn up at auctions all the time, and thousands of shooters still rely on heirloom pieces—an old Model 10 or Police Positive a relative carried on the job, for example. That same longevity shows up in concealed-carry classics too: Smith & Wesson “Lemon Squeezer” hammerless models, Iver Johnson Safety Automatics (which are revolvers), Colt Detective Specials and Cobras, S&W J-frames, and Ruger Speed-Six snubbies all continue to see regular use decades after they were made.
Part of the reason is wear: provided a revolver hasn’t been abused with constant hot loads, it usually endures far less stress than a semi-automatic. Common revolver cartridges such as the .38 Special, .45 Long Colt or, more rarely, the .44 Special, operate at much lower chamber pressures than many semi-auto rounds. The ubiquitous 9×19mm, for instance, can generate on the order of 33,000 psi, while .38 Special runs closer to 17,000 psi. Lower pressure means less stress on the frame, cylinder and timing components.
Combine that with a stout, all-metal frame and you get a firearm that simply won’t “shoot out” for many years. As long as the timing—the cylinder indexing precisely so each chamber lines up with the barrel—remains correct and the gun is properly maintained, a revolver will give you a lot of trouble-free shooting.
Concealed Carry Revolvers Meet Magazine Restrictions
For states like California, New York, Maryland and others that heavily restrict the number of rounds a handgun can carry, concealed carry revolvers are virtually unscathed. While smaller concealed carry models typically hold 5, the maximum commonly found is 6-8. This is all well under the legal limit, meaning those that carry revolvers don't have to worry about shopping around for magazines.
Revolvers are Iconic
Old style Smith & Wessons have a tried and true appearance which a lot of gun owners appreciate. There are plenty more revolver manufacturers out there than S&W, but the iconic look is somewhat appealing for some concealed carriers. And something that's that good never goes out of style.
A good number of people appreciate the aesthetics of a firearm. Blued steel and wood never go out of style, even for a concealed carry revolver, and black plastic just leaves so much to be desired.
FAQs
What makes a revolver suitable for concealed carry?
A revolver chosen for concealed carry typically features a compact frame, lightweight materials, and a short barrel length, often categorized as snub-nose revolvers. Popular models like the Smith & Wesson J-Frame or Ruger LCR are designed to be easily concealable and comfortable for everyday use. Caliber choices often balance between manageable recoil and stopping power, with .38 Special and .357 Magnum being common options. Selecting an appropriate holster that covers the trigger guard and fits the carry position is crucial for safety and accessibility.
Is it legal to carry a concealed revolver?
Concealed carry laws vary by state and locality, with some requiring a permit or license and others allowing permitless carry. It is critical to research your area's specific legal requirements, which include permit application processes, reciprocity agreements with other states, and restrictions on carrying in certain public places. Ensuring compliance with local concealed carry regulations helps avoid legal issues related to firearm possession.
How does a revolver compare to semi-automatic pistols for concealed carry?
Revolvers offer mechanical simplicity, reliability, and ease of use with fewer moving parts, which can reduce malfunctions. They typically have a lower ammunition capacity, usually 5 to 6 rounds, but avoid issues like stovepiping common in semi-automatics. Revolvers often have a heavier trigger pull which may impact rapid fire but provide a straightforward safety mechanism. Concealed carriers may prefer revolvers for their ruggedness and straightforward operation.
What caliber is recommended for concealed carry revolvers?
Common calibers for concealed carry revolvers include .38 Special, .357 Magnum, and .327 Federal Magnum. The .38 Special is widely favored for its moderate recoil and proven stopping power, making it suitable for most shooters. The .357 Magnum offers increased ballistic performance but produces more recoil, requiring greater shooter proficiency. The choice depends on the balance between stopping power, recoil management, and comfort in carry and shooting.
What are the best carry positions and holster types for revolvers?
Popular carry positions for concealed revolvers include appendix carry (1-2 o'clock), hip carry (3-5 o'clock), and small-of-back (12 o'clock). Comfort, concealability, and draw speed influence choice. Holster materials such as leather and Kydex offer varying degrees of retention, comfort, and durability. A quality holster fully covers the trigger guard, fits the specific revolver model, and complements the chosen carry position to optimize safety and accessibility.
How do I maintain proficiency in using a concealed carry revolver?
Regular practice drawing from your holster and live-fire training at the range are essential to build muscle memory and accuracy. Incorporating dry-fire practice with snap caps improves trigger control without live rounds. Understanding the revolver's single-action and double-action trigger pulls and practicing reload techniques will enhance readiness in a self-defense situation.
What are safety considerations when carrying a concealed revolver?
Always keep the trigger guard fully covered with a proper holster to prevent accidental discharges. Many modern revolvers feature transfer bars or hammer blocks as internal safety mechanisms allowing all chambers to be safely loaded. Be mindful of local laws regarding carrying fully loaded firearms and understand legal liabilities involved in the use of deadly force. Training on situational awareness, safe handling, and storage complements physical safety measures.