What’s the difference between the Bodyguard 380 and the Glock 42? In short, the Bodyguard 380 is slimmer and integrates a built-in laser option for deep concealment, while the Glock 42 offers classic Glock reliability and a smoother trigger in a slightly larger frame.
The Bodyguard 380 excels when absolute minimal print and pocket carry matter most. Its compact frame and lighter weight make it easy to forget it’s even there. Meanwhile, the Glock 42 gives you a more comfortable shooting experience and proven reliability under stress, ideal if you want a balance between concealability and control.
Both cater to daily carry, but your choice should reflect whether you value ultimate concealment or a more forgiving grip and handling. Choose the one that fits your comfort level, draw confidence, and daily routine — without second-guessing your decision when it counts.
Key Takeaways
- The Smith & Wesson Bodyguard 380 and Glock 42 are both excellent concealed carry options, but they cater to different needs based on size, handling, and performance.
- The Bodyguard 380 excels in deep concealment due to its ultra-compact size and lightweight design, making it ideal for discreet everyday carry or backup roles.
- The Glock 42 offers superior ergonomics, a longer barrel for better accuracy, and reduced recoil, making it more suitable for shooters prioritizing comfort during extended use or range training.
- While the Bodyguard 380's double-action-only (DAO) trigger adds safety against accidental discharges, the Glock 42’s lighter trigger pull enhances speed and precision under stress.
- Both pistols are reliable with quality ammunition; however, the Glock 42 benefits from broader aftermarket customization options compared to the limited upgrades available for the Bodyguard 380.
- Choosing between these firearms depends on your priorities—whether it's maximum concealability with the Bodyguard 380 or enhanced shootability and versatility with the Glock 42.
Quick Verdict — Which Gun is Better for You?
Choosing between the Bodyguard 380 and Glock 42 depends on your specific needs, experience level, and intended use. Both firearms are excellent options for concealed carry but cater to different priorities.
| Feature | Bodyguard 380 | Glock 42 |
|---|---|---|
| Overall Length | 5.25 inches | 5.94 inches |
| Weight (unloaded) | 12 oz | 13.76 oz |
| Barrel Length | 2.75 inches | 3.25 inches |
| Caliber | .380 ACP | .380 ACP |
| Capacity | 6+1 | 6+1 (with extended mags available) |
| Trigger Type | Double-action only (DAO) | Striker-fired |
| Ergonomics | Ultra-compact, ideal for deep concealment | Better grip comfort and control |
| Best Use Case | Deep concealment, backup carry | Versatile carry, range practice, easier handling |
Concealment and Size
The Bodyguard 380 excels in deep concealment scenarios due to its smaller dimensions. Measuring approximately 5.25 inches in length and weighing just 12 ounces unloaded, it’s ideal if you prioritize minimal printing under light clothing or need a backup firearm. The slim profile fits well with IWB (inside-the-waistband) holsters or appendix carry setups, especially those made from durable materials like Boltaron by Alien Gear Holsters.
In contrast, the Glock 42 offers slightly larger dimensions at about 5.94 inches long and an unloaded weight of 13.76 ounces. While still compact, this added size improves grip comfort for shooters with medium-to-large hands. It remains highly concealable but may require a more robust holster system, such as OWB (outside-the-waistband) or hybrid designs combining neoprene backers with rigid shells.
Handling and Ergonomics
If you're new to firearms or prefer simplicity during operation, the Glock 42 stands out with its intuitive design and consistent trigger pull. Its ergonomic grip angle enhances control during rapid fire or extended range sessions. Competitive shooters often appreciate its predictable recoil pattern when practicing drills like controlled pairs or failure-to-stop scenarios.
The Bodyguard 380 incorporates a double-action-only (DAO) trigger system that some users find challenging without regular practice. But, this feature adds an extra layer of safety against accidental discharges in high-stress situations—a potential advantage for law enforcement officers using it as a secondary weapon.
Reliability and Performance
Both pistols demonstrate reliable performance with quality ammunition brands like Federal Premium or Hornady Critical Defense rounds. The Glock 42 has earned a reputation among enthusiasts for feeding hollow points consistently without malfunctions during extensive testing periods exceeding several hundred rounds per session.
While dependable overall, the Bodyguard 380 may occasionally encounter feed issues depending on magazine condition or ammo type, something experienced gun owners can mitigate through proper maintenance and selecting compatible loads.
Customization Potential
Glock's aftermarket ecosystem surpasses most competitors, including Smith & Wesson's offerings for the Bodyguard series. With numerous sights, triggers, slide plates, and mag extensions available from reputable manufacturers like Trijicon or Vickers Tactical, you can easily tailor the Glock 42 to fit personal preferences or mission-specific requirements.
The Bodyguard supports fewer upgrades but accommodates essentials like laser sight attachments integrated into certain models—a practical choice if low-light engagements are part of your defensive considerations.
Practical Use Cases
For everyday concealed carry in urban environments where discretion matters most, the Bodyguard 380 shines due to its ultra-compact frame and lightweight build. It's also suitable as an ankle-carry option for professionals needing discreet access while seated.
The Glock 42 suits broader applications ranging from home defense to range training thanks to its shootability and reliability under sustained use. If you're planning frequent practice sessions involving dynamic movement drills or competitive matches requiring precision shots beyond seven yards, this pistol provides greater versatility.
Key Specs Breakdown
Design & Ergonomics
The Bodyguard 380 and Glock 42 differ significantly in design and ergonomics, catering to distinct user preferences.
The Bodyguard 380 features a compact polymer frame with integrated laser sight options, making it ideal for deep concealment. Its slim profile measures 0.75 inches wide, ensuring minimal printing under clothing. But, its smaller grip may feel less comfortable for users with larger hands.
The Glock 42 offers a slightly larger frame at 0.94 inches wide, improving grip stability without sacrificing concealability. Its ergonomic design includes textured surfaces for better control during rapid fire or high-stress scenarios.
While the Glock lacks an integrated laser option, its accessory rail supports aftermarket attachments like lights or lasers. Both models accommodate IWB (inside-the-waistband) holsters effectively; but, the Bodyguard’s size also suits pocket carry setups.
Caliber & Barrel Length
Both pistols are chambered in .380 ACP, a popular caliber for concealed carry due to manageable recoil and sufficient stopping power at close range. The Bodyguard 380 has a barrel length of 2.75 inches, contributing to its compact form factor but slightly reducing muzzle velocity compared to longer barrels.
The Glock 42 features a longer barrel at 3.25 inches, enhancing accuracy and ballistic performance while maintaining ease of concealment. This difference becomes noticeable during range training or defensive shooting drills where precision matters most.
For ammunition compatibility, both firearms reliably cycle standard-pressure .380 ACP rounds; but, testing specific loads ensures optimal reliability based on your intended use case.
Capacity & Magazine Options
Magazine capacity is another area where these pistols diverge slightly. The Bodyguard 380 ships with a standard six-round magazine and often includes an extended floorplate option for improved grip comfort without increasing capacity.
The Glock 42 also comes with a six-round magazine but benefits from broader aftermarket support offering extended magazines that increase capacity by one or two rounds while preserving reliability.
Competitive shooters or law enforcement professionals may prefer the flexibility provided by these upgrades when additional firepower is necessary in training environments or tactical applications.
Both firearms pair well with spare magazine carriers designed for OWB (outside-the-waistband) or appendix carry positions to ensure quick reloads during defensive situations.
Trigger Performance & Safety Features
Trigger systems play a critical role in firearm handling and safety dynamics between these models. The Bodyguard 380 employs a double-action-only (DAO) trigger system with an approximate pull weight of nine pounds. This heavier pull adds an extra layer of safety against accidental discharges but requires practice to master consistent shot placement under stress.
In contrast, the Glock 42 uses Glock’s Safe Action System featuring a lighter five-and-a-half-pound trigger pull with built-in safeties that engage automatically until deliberate pressure is applied to the trigger face. This setup promotes faster follow-up shots and greater accuracy during timed drills or defensive engagements.
For added security during concealed carry scenarios, both models lack manual external safeties but rely on their respective trigger mechanisms as primary safeguards against unintended firing events when paired with quality holsters like Alien Gear Holsters made from durable Boltaron material for secure retention and safe draw/reholstering practices.
Shooting Performance in the Field
Accuracy & Grouping
The Glock 42 demonstrates superior accuracy due to its longer barrel length of 3.25 inches, providing a more stable sight radius. This advantage becomes evident during range sessions or defensive drills where precise shot placement is critical. Its lighter trigger pull further aids in maintaining consistent grouping, especially for shooters with moderate experience levels.
The Bodyguard 380, with its shorter 2.75-inch barrel and heavier double-action-only (DAO) trigger, requires more practice to achieve tight groupings. While it excels at close-range engagements typical of concealed carry scenarios, you might notice wider shot dispersion beyond 10 yards compared to the Glock 42. For new gun owners or those prioritizing ease of use under stress, the Glock's intuitive design may enhance field performance.
Reliability & Durability
Both pistols maintain solid reputations for reliability but differ slightly in long-term durability under extensive use. The Glock 42 benefits from Glock’s renowned polymer frame construction and Tenifer-treated slide, which resist wear and corrosion effectively even after thousands of rounds fired.
Competitive shooters and law enforcement professionals often favor this model for its ability to endure high round counts without significant maintenance concerns.
The Bodyguard 380 offers reliable operation within its intended role as a low-profile concealed carry firearm but may encounter occasional feed issues with certain ammunition types, particularly hollow points.
Regular cleaning mitigates these occurrences, making it suitable for civilian users who prioritize portability over extended range sessions or heavy-duty applications.
Recoil and Handling for Different Use Cases
Recoil management varies significantly between these models due to their size and weight differences. The Glock 42’s slightly larger frame and ergonomic grip reduce felt recoil noticeably compared to the smaller Bodyguard 380. This makes follow-up shots quicker and smoother during home defense drills or competitive shooting events requiring rapid target transitions.
In contrast, the Bodyguard 380’s compact dimensions result in snappier recoil that can challenge newer shooters during prolonged training sessions.
Concealed Carry & Practical Use
Comfort for Daily Carry
Both the Bodyguard 380 and Glock 42 are designed with concealed carry in mind, but their dimensions and ergonomics affect daily comfort differently. The Bodyguard 380's compact frame (5.25 inches overall length) and lighter weight of 12 ounces make it nearly unnoticeable during all-day wear. Its slim profile minimizes printing under fitted clothing, making it a preferred choice for deep concealment scenarios like appendix or pocket carry.
The Glock 42, while slightly larger at 5.94 inches long and weighing 13.76 ounces unloaded, offers enhanced grip ergonomics due to its broader backstrap and taller frame.
This design provides better control during extended use but may require more consideration when selecting an inside-the-waistband (IWB) holster to maintain discretion.
Draw Speed & Accessibility
Quick access is critical in defensive situations, and both pistols offer unique advantages depending on your carry method. The Bodyguard 380’s smaller size allows faster retrieval from tight spaces such as ankle holsters or small compartments, ideal for users prioritizing maximum concealability over rapid follow-up shots.
But, its double-action-only trigger system requires deliberate effort, which can slightly slow initial engagement if you're not accustomed to the heavier pull.
The Glock 42 excels in draw speed when paired with OWB or appendix carry setups due to its consistent single-action-like trigger pull and ergonomic grip angle that promotes natural alignment upon presentation.
Its longer slide also aids in achieving a firm purchase during the draw stroke, reducing fumble risks under stress. For optimal accessibility, consider pairing either firearm with adjustable cant holsters that align with your dominant hand's natural motion path.
Holster Recommendations
Selecting the right holster ensures secure carry and quick access for both the Bodyguard 380 and Glock 42. Each firearm's size, weight, and intended use influence holster compatibility.
OWB, IWB, Appendix, Chest & Other Options
OWB (Outside-the-Waistband): OWB holsters suit open carry or range training scenarios. For the Glock 42, options like Kydex or Boltaron models provide durability and retention. The Bodyguard 380 benefits from compact OWB designs that minimize bulk while maintaining accessibility.
IWB (Inside-the-Waistband): IWB holsters are ideal for concealed carry. Alien Gear’s Boltaron IWB holsters offer comfort and concealment for both pistols. The Glock 42’s slightly larger frame may require a deeper tuck to reduce printing, while the Bodyguard 380 fits seamlessly in slimmer profiles.
Appendix Carry: Appendix rigs enhance draw speed but demand proper trigger guard coverage for safety. Both firearms perform well with appendix-specific holsters due to their compact dimensions. Ensure adjustable cant angles to optimize positioning.
Chest Rigs: Chest holsters cater to outdoor activities like hiking or biking. Lightweight chest rigs accommodate the Bodyguard 380 effectively without adding strain. The Glock 42 pairs better with structured designs offering additional stability during movement.
Other Options: Pocket holsters complement the Bodyguard 380’s small frame for discreet carry in casual attire. Ankle holsters also work well for backup roles. For the Glock 42, hybrid systems combining leather backers with rigid shells balance comfort and retention across various applications.
Will a Bodyguard 380 Fit in a Glock 42 Holster or Viceversa?
No, the Smith & Wesson Bodyguard 380 will not properly fit in a Glock 42 holster, and the Glock 42 will not fit securely in a Bodyguard 380 holster.
While both are compact .380 ACP pistols, they differ in dimensions, frame shape, and trigger guard profile. These variations prevent proper retention and can cause safety or draw issues.
For best fit and function, always use a holster designed specifically for your firearm model.
Final Thoughts — Which One Should You Choose?
Choosing between the Bodyguard 380 and Glock 42 eventually comes down to your personal needs and priorities. If deep concealment, lightweight design, and discreet carry are at the top of your list, the Bodyguard 380 might be the better fit. On the other hand, if you value enhanced grip comfort, consistent performance, and a broader range of customization options, the Glock 42 stands out as a versatile choice.
Both pistols offer reliable solutions for concealed carry but cater to different preferences. Consider factors like your experience level, intended use, and how each firearm feels in your hands before making a decision. Whichever you choose, investing time in practice and proper holster selection will ensure you're prepared for any situation.
Frequently Asked Questions
1. Which pistol is better for deep concealment: Smith & Wesson Bodyguard 380 or Glock 42?
The Smith & Wesson Bodyguard 380 is better for deep concealment due to its smaller size and lighter weight, making it less likely to print under clothing.
2. Is the Glock 42 more reliable than the Bodyguard 380?
Yes, the Glock 42 is known for its consistent reliability and performance, while the Bodyguard 380 may occasionally experience feed issues.
3. Which handgun has a better trigger system?
The Glock 42 features a lighter trigger pull with built-in safeties, ideal for quick follow-up shots. The Bodyguard 380 has a heavier double-action-only trigger, offering added safety but requiring more practice.
4. Can I customize both pistols easily?
The Glock 42 offers more extensive aftermarket customization options compared to the Bodyguard 380, which supports fewer upgrades but allows essential attachments like laser sights.
5. What are the key differences in magazine capacity between these two models?
Both pistols come with a standard six-round magazine; however, the Glock 42 has broader aftermarket support for extended magazines.
6. Which gun is easier to handle for beginners?
The Glock 42 is easier to handle for beginners due to its intuitive design, ergonomic grip, and consistent trigger pull.
7. How does recoil management compare between these two pistols?
The Glock 42 provides superior recoil management and accuracy, making it suitable for extended use. The Bodyguard 380 handles well at close range but may feel less stable during rapid fire.
8. Are there holster options available for both firearms?
Yes, both firearms have various holster options available. The Bodyguard 380 works well with compact OWB and pocket holsters, while the Glock 42 benefits from durable OWB and hybrid systems.
9. Which pistol is better suited for home defense?
The Glock 42 is better suited for home defense due to its improved grip comfort, accuracy, and versatility in different scenarios.
10. What makes the Bodyguard 380 unique compared to other concealed carry guns?
The Bodyguard 380 stands out with its ultra-compact frame and integrated laser sight options that enhance discreet everyday carry capabilities.