S&W M&P40 Pistol Review & Complete Buyer’s Guide

The S&W M&P40 pistol is a full-size, striker-fired .40 S&W handgun designed to deliver duty-level durability, controllable recoil, and reliable function across defensive, competition, and law-enforcement environments.

Built around a polymer frame with steel inserts, a Melonite-treated stainless slide, interchangeable backstraps, and the M2.0 trigger system, the M&P40 blends ergonomics with performance in a cartridge known for its sharper recoil behavior.

With 15+1 capacity and optional optics-ready or Performance Center configurations, it remains a strong choice for shooters who prefer the terminal characteristics of .40 S&W.

Photo Credits

What is the S&W M&P40 pistol and why does it matter in today’s market?

The Smith & Wesson M&P40 matters because it offers a modern, reliable, and well-balanced .40 S&W platform at a time when many manufacturers have toned down their .40-caliber offerings.

For shooters who prefer .40 S&W for its energy profile, penetration, and defensive track record, the M&P40 delivers a contemporary package with excellent ergonomics and proven service reliability.

Its M2.0 refinements—trigger, texture, frame stiffness, and sighting options—make it a strong contender for duty carry and civilian defensive roles.

Brief overview of Smith & Wesson’s design lineage

Smith & Wesson has a long history of designing service pistols optimized for reliability and shooter interface.

The M&P series, launched in 2005, aimed to modernize striker-fired handguns with user-customizable backstraps, ambidextrous controls, and improved grip geometry. The M&P40 was part of the original lineup, designed specifically for .40 S&W at a time when law enforcement heavily favored the caliber.

The later M2.0 revision strengthened the internal chassis, deepened the grip texture, and improved the trigger quality, directly addressing user feedback from the 1.0 generation.

Intended purpose and user profile

The M&P40 pistol is built for shooters who want more energy than 9mm without stepping into large-frame .45 ACP territory. Its intended roles include:

• Duty or security work

• Home defense

• Defensive concealed carry (compact variants)

• Competition divisions where .40 scoring offers advantages

• Shooters comfortable managing .40 recoil who prioritize stopping power

Its combination of capacity, ergonomics, and ballistic performance keeps it relevant even as market trends shift.

What are the full technical specifications of the S&W M&P40 pistol?

The S&W M&P40 pistol is a striker-fired, polymer-frame handgun with a 4.25-inch barrel, 15+1 capacity, and durable Melonite-treated components. Built for longevity and reliability, it weighs about 28 ounces unloaded and maintains a slim profile that balances concealability with shootability.

Caliber: .40 S&W
Action: Striker-fired
Barrel Length: ~4.25 inches
Overall Length: ~7.5 inches
Height: ~5.5 inches
Width: ~1.2 inches
Weight: ~28 oz (unloaded)
Magazine Capacity: 15+1 standard; 10-round compliant versions available
Frame: Polymer with reinforced steel chassis
Slide/Barrel: Stainless steel with Melonite finish
Trigger: M2.0 flat-faced trigger with tactile reset (variant dependent)
Sights: 3-dot, night sights, or fiber optic (PC models)
Optics Ready: Available on C.O.R.E. and M2.0 optics-ready versions
Rail: Picatinny rail for lights and lasers
Safety Options: Ambidextrous slide stop, reversible magazine release, optional manual safety

How is the S&W M&P40 constructed and what design principles shape it?

The M&P40 is constructed around a polymer frame with a steel-reinforced internal chassis that stiffens the structure and reduces flex during recoil.

This design helps maintain slide alignment, improves lockup consistency, and enhances durability during high-round-count use with snappier .40 S&W forces. The stainless steel slide and barrel undergo Melonite treatment, increasing surface hardness, corrosion resistance, and overall service life.

Frame materials and ergonomics

The polymer frame utilizes interchangeable backstraps—Small, Medium, Medium-Large, and Large—allowing shooters to adjust grip circumference and trigger reach.

The M2.0 texture is noticeably more aggressive, providing secure traction without being overly abrasive during extended sessions. The grip angle aligns the wrist in a natural forward rotation, which reduces muzzle rise and aids in tracking the front sight after each shot.

Controls and operating system

The pistol’s controls are ambidextrous or reversible. The slide stop is mirrored on both sides, while the magazine release can be flipped for left-handed shooters. The M2.0 trigger system improves the break and provides a substantially better reset than the 1.0 generation. Many shooters transitioning from the older hinged trigger describe the new trigger as a dramatic improvement in consistency and confidence.

Accessory and optics compatibility

The M&P40’s dustcover rail supports compact and full-size weapon lights. Optics-ready variants (C.O.R.E. / M2.0 OR) include slide cuts for popular red dots. Performance Center models often include taller sights or adjustable sights for precision-oriented users.

What variants of the S&W M&P40 are available and how do they differ?

The M&P40 lineup includes several frame sizes and configurations, spanning duty, tactical, competition, and concealed-carry roles. Differences center on barrel length, optics cuts, trigger tuning, sight options, and Performance Center enhancements.

Full-Size vs Compact vs Subcompact

• Full-Size M&P40: 4.25-inch barrel, 15+1 capacity, ideal for duty or home defense.

• M&P40 Compact (M2.0 generation): Shorter grip and slide, reduced capacity, better for concealed carry.

• Older Subcompact models: Discontinued in many configurations but still in circulation; excel in deep concealment.

Optics-Ready C.O.R.E. Models

These variants include a milled slide for mounting red-dot optics, making them suitable for defensive carry or practical competition.

Performance Center Editions

PC models typically include:

• Ported barrels and slides for reduced muzzle rise

• Enhanced triggers

• Fiber-optic or tall sights

• Lightened slide geometry for faster cycling

Comparison to Similar Pistols

Glock 22 / 23:

The Glock series has more aftermarket support, but many shooters find the M&P40 better in ergonomics and natural point of aim.

Sig Sauer P226 (.40):

Heavier, softer shooting, but lower capacity and higher cost. The M&P40 is more practical for modern carry.

Springfield XD(M) .40:

Comparable performance, but many prefer the M2.0 trigger and chassis stiffness.

How does the S&W M&P40 perform in real-world shooting conditions?

The M&P40 pistol performs with consistent accuracy, reliable function, and controlled recoil for a .40-caliber handgun. Its M2.0 trigger and improved grip texture provide noticeable upgrades in shot-to-shot consistency.

Accuracy and consistency

Most shooters achieve 2–3" groups at 10–15 yards with defensive loads. The pistol’s sight radius and low muzzle flip contribute to effective accuracy under speed. Red-dot-equipped M&P40s tighten groups further, especially during rapid transitions.

Recoil management

.40 S&W generates a sharper impulse than 9mm, but the M&P40’s combination of bore axis, grip angle, and texture helps mitigate muzzle rise. Many shooters describe the recoil as “assertive but straight back,” making it more manageable than some competing polymer .40s.

Reliability

The M&P40 platform is known for feeding reliability with FMJ and JHP loads across major manufacturers. It cycles well with standard and duty-rated ammunition. High-round-count users frequently report minimal wear and stable performance past thousands of rounds.

Trigger performance

The M2.0 trigger breaks cleanly with a tactile, audible reset. This flatter geometry aids in managing .40 recoil by encouraging consistent finger placement and follow-through.

What ammunition types work best in the S&W M&P40?

The M&P40 handles a broad range of commercial ammunition reliably, from lightweight 155gr defensive loads to 180gr bonded JHP duty rounds. It functions well with both target FMJ and higher-pressure defensive loads.

Best grain weights

• 165gr JHP: Fast expansion, strong defensive performance.

• 180gr JHP: Balanced recoil and deep penetration.

• 155gr FMJ: Popular training load with slightly lighter recoil.

Recommended defensive loads

• Speer Gold Dot 180gr

• Federal HST 180gr

• Winchester Ranger 165gr

• Hornady Critical Duty 175gr FlexLock

Feeding and extraction characteristics

The chamber and feed ramp geometry handle hollow points reliably. Users rarely report extraction issues unless using low-powered reloads or excessively dirty ammunition.

Is the S&W M&P40 suitable for concealed carry?

The full-size M&P40 can be concealed with the right holster, though the compact M2.0 variant is more practical for everyday carry. Shooters willing to manage additional recoil will find it effective for self-defense, offering more energy than 9mm without stepping up to a larger-caliber frame.

Home defense suitability

The rail system allows pairing with weapon lights, and optics-ready models expand target acquisition options. Its 15+1 capacity and controllable recoil make it an excellent home-defense handgun.

Competition use

In IDPA or USPSA, .40 S&W scoring can offer meaningful advantages. The M&P40’s ergonomics and trigger make it competitive, especially in Performance Center configurations.

Outdoor or hunting utility

While not a hunting pistol, the .40 S&W chambering provides enough energy for small to medium predators. Its durability and reliability suit field carry.

Range and training use

The M2.0 trigger and grip texture make long sessions engaging, though recoil fatigue may appear sooner than with 9mm variants.

What is the best S&W M&P40 holster setup?

Selecting a S&W M&P40 holster depends on whether you prioritize concealed carry, open carry, training, or duty performance. The following holster types match the pistol’s size and intended uses.

ShapeShift IWB Holster

This S&W M&P40 holster supports deep concealment while distributing frame pressure across a broad surface. Its adjustability helps fine-tune ride height and cant for comfort.

Belt Holster

A belt-mounted S&W M&P40 holster is ideal for open carry or range use, keeping the handgun stable during movement and providing a consistent draw angle.

OWB Paddle Holster

This S&W M&P40 holster offers fast attachment and removal, making it convenient for training sessions or home-defense ready positions.

Rapid Force Level 2 Retention

This S&W M&P40 holster adds fast, intuitive Level 2 retention suited for duty environments and high-mobility scenarios. Its gross motor response release method supports rapid, confident draws.

Rapid Force Level 3 Retention

A Level 3 S&W M&P40 holster offers maximum retention without compromising draw efficiency. Its added security benefits law enforcement and users operating in dynamic or physical environments.

What are the main strengths and limitations of the M&P40?

Pros

• Strong ergonomics mitigate .40 recoil

• Excellent reliability with a wide range of ammunition

• M2.0 trigger offers improved break and reset

• Durable construction with Melonite-treated components

• High 15+1 capacity in a duty-size frame

• Optics-ready and PC variants increase versatility

Cons

• Recoil is sharper than 9mm and may fatigue newer shooters

• Full-size version is harder to conceal

• 1.0 triggers are noticeably inferior to M2.0

• Smaller aftermarket ecosystem compared to Glock .40 models

Is the S&W M&P40 pistol worth it?

The S&W M&P40 remains one of the strongest .40 S&W polymer pistols available, offering reliability, proven ergonomics, modern features, and capacity appropriate for defensive roles.

Shooters who value .40 caliber performance will appreciate the M2.0 trigger, improved chassis stability, and accessory support. It is ideal for home defense, duty carry, and users confident with .40 recoil.

With long-term durability, strong factory support, and multiple model configurations, the M&P40 pistol continues to provide excellent value in the full-size defensive handgun category.